In Historic Order:

* William Heyman 1914-’15
* Joseph J. Glatzma 1915-’16
* Charles R. Norman 1916-’17
* George H. Wells 1917-’18
* J.F. Stuart 1918-’19
* Henry G.E. Pansius 1919-’21
* FW Gertzen 1921-’23
* C.S. Levitt 1923-’24
* R.G. Narelle 1924-’25
* James H. Condon 1925-’27
* Robert R. Barr 1927-’29
* James F. Cullen 1929-’31
* David T. Lamond 1931-’33
* Thomas F. Baker 1933-’34
* Charles Dougherty 1935-’37
* Terence P. Cook 1939-’41
* William J. Honan 1941-’43
* James A. Dennean 1943-’45
* Edward Broderick 1945-’47
* Theodore Sattler 1947-’49
* Paul G. Boise 1949-’53
* Hubert C. Magee 1953-’53
* James McAllister 1953-’55
* Ferguson Smith 1955-’56
* Gus P. Chiarello 1956-’58
* Erwin Wedemann 1958-’60
* Harry S. Tiel 1960-’62
* Vincent J. Griffin 1962-’62
* James E. Krebs 1962-’65
* James B. Doden 1965-’67
* William J. Shields 1967-’69
* Peter E. Edwards 1969-’71
* Eugene D. Lynch 1971-’73
* Vincent Wortman 1973-’75
* Joseph M. Harkin 1975-’76
* Philip C. Devine 1976-’77
* Lawrence Brower 1977-’79
* John Grifhorn Jr. 1979-’81
Richard Hanel Sr. 1981-’83
* John J. McEnaney 1983-’85
* Frank J. Fils 1985-’86
Lee di Paci 1986-’88
Robert Hannon 1988-’89
* James Farrell Jr. 1989-’91
* Anthony DeMaria 1991-’95
Charles Driscoll 1996-’98
Thomas Moynihan 1999-’01
Tony DiBennedetto 2002-’11
Bryan Jay 2012-‘13
Walter Carney 2014-‘15

*Deceased